It's a Wireless World: Router Roundup

Share

If local area networks (LANs) were like plumbing, then Ethernet cables would be the pipes and routers the valve switchers. But data bits have a huge advantage over fluids. They don't require conduits to flow through your home or office to still be useful.


Bits can be transmitted through the air, walls and floors and arrive where needed, intact. Wireless network technology has empowered the growing array of Wi-Fi appliances, and it's not just about computers anymore.

Since wireless routers usually contain four LAN (RJ-45) ports that accept Ethernet cables, they start out as wired routers. (An RJ-45 input is a wider version of the RJ-11 snap-in connection on phones.) The difference is that the wireless version also includes an antenna (external or embedded) and a radio that sends and receives data to compatible devices within a couple of hundred feet.

Almost all routers include a wide area network (WAN) port, which is yet another RJ-45, for connecting the local network to the wider digital world known as the Internet. An Ethernet cable links the router ,most often in homes, to a cable modem. Though they look the same, the WAN port usually sports a different color than the LAN ports.

With the rise of wireless Internet access through 3G cellular phone networks, some specialized routers let you create an instant hot spot for use by several of your Wi-Fi devices no matter where you happen to be, providing you can pick up the wireless broadband service to which you subscribe. People who own recreational vehicles or attend tailgate parties or go camping could bring along a notebook computer and iPod Touch and share a ramp to the Internet in their ad hoc hot spot.

Cellular routers typically get their broadband connection using the same types of modems you'd slide into the PCMCIA slot of a notebook computer or plug into a USB port. An important difference between them is which type of interface they accommodate. While the Netgear 3G Broadband Wireless Router only accepts USB-type modems, the D-Link 3G Mobile Router for EV-DO Networks and Aluratek 3G Wireless USB/PCMCIA Cellular Router (left) accept both types.

Wireless broadband speed still pales by comparison to that of a cable modem, so transmitting within a hot spot using the older Wi-Fi standards (802.11b/g) is good enough. However, if you're at home or in a hotel room using a cable TV-based Internet service provider or a Digital Subscriber Line (DSL) from your phone company, you can take advantage of the faster throughput using a wireless router that integrates the newer 802.11n standard (or the less-supported 802.11a standard).

The 802.11n "standard" was finally ratified last September by an industry consortium. (For the previous few years, products with "n" specs were referred to as "draft -N.") So, it's still a good time to replace your aging router with an 802.11n type, especially if you recently bought a computer or media receiver that supports the protocol or if you expect to buy one soon. (The 802.11n standard routers are downwardly-compatible to 802.11b/g equipment, so you can continue to use a range of devices.) The advantage of 802.11n wireless connections is that data is transmitted two to seven times faster than 802.11g networks. The performance gap is most noticeable at 300 feet—the outside range of a G-type network. If you send or receive high-definition video (originating from your camcorder or streamed from the Internet), and you do it wirelessly, you'll need an 802.11n or 802.11a network no matter how far apart your devices are placed . If you're using an 802.11b/g-type router, high-def video will stutter and stall. Without an upgrade, you're better off sticking to Ethernet cables.

The 802.11n router may incorporate a radio technology called MIMO (for "multiple input multiple output") that uses multiple antennas at both the transmitting and receiving ends to improve communication performance. The most advanced 802.11n routers are also dual band, transmitting simultaneously at 2.4 and 5 Gigahertz. This is a way of avoiding the crowded 2.4GHz frequency used by older Wi-Fi networks, some cordless phones, baby monitors and microwave ovens.

Among your options are the D-Link Xtreme N Dual Band Gigabit Router (above) and Linksys Simultaneous Dual-N Band Wireless Router. The newest notebooks incorporate Dual-Band Wireless N transceivers, but if you want to upgrade an older notebook (especially one with built-in 802.11g Wi-Fi) or a desktop computer that can't be conveniently hooked up to an Ethernet cable, consider a USB or PCMCIA (PC Card) adapter with N Dual Band capability. Single band (2.4GHz) N routers include the D-Link Wireless N Router and Linksys Wireless-N Home Router (below).

The older 802.11b/g wireless standard continues to bring value to home network enthusiasts whose data requirements top out at music, photos and standard-definition video and don't push range limits. These routers are usually less expensive than N-type routers. They include the Linksys RangePlus Wireless Router and Netgear 54 Mbps Wireless Router. A b/g router with extra reach is the Bountiful WiFi BWRG1000 Long Range Wireless 802.11b/g Router. If you have DSL service, you might consider the Netgear Wireless-G ADSL Modem Router. It eliminates a separate DSL modem and the phone company's rental charge. Better still, if you want the advantages of a built-in DSL modem and N-type wireless connectivity, consider the Netgear Wireless-N Router with Built-in DSL Modem.

A benefit of installing any router—including ones conforming to the conventional 802.11b/g wireless standards—is that it contains a firewall to help protect your computer against malicious attacks from other users on the Internet. Additionally, routers feature network security software to protect your data as it is transmitted wirelessly, ensuring that outsiders can't access your files or piggyback on your broadband connection to the Internet. In the box with every router is normally a CD-ROM that you run on a LAN-linked computer. You use it to name your network, pick a password, and choose the type of security.

In terms of security, Wi-Fi Protected Access (WPA2) has eclipsed the less secure Wired Equivalent Privacy (WEP) protocol. Also, 256-bit security is more secure than 128-bit, which is more secure than 64-bit. Other acronyms to recognize in the accompanying chart: Pre-Shared Key (PSK) mode; Personal Information Number (PIN); Push Button Configuration (PBC); Media Access Control (MAC) address. It's not necessary to understand this technical jargon in setting up your router. A lot of the setup today is guided and nearly automatic. What is important is that you remember your password and keep it secret unless you don't mind neighbors borrowing your bandwidth to access the Internet. Apple's AirPort Extreme Base Station lets you set up a separate Wi-Fi network with a separate password for guests so they can get on the internet without having access to your computers.

As for additional wired features, some routers now include a USB port for a shared printer or a Network Attached Storage (NAS) device. Apple's AirPort Extreme and D-Link's Xtreme N Gigabit (DIR-655) and Xtreme N Dual Band (DIR-825) Routers, for instance, each let you attach a compatible printer to its port so that several computers on your home or office network can share it wirelessly. As for an NAS device, the advantage is that several computers or media receivers on your network may be able to access such centralized storage. Two N-type wireless routers with USB ports are the Linksys Wireless-N Broadband Router with Storage Link and Belkin N+ Wireless Router (right). Alternatively, there are plenty of network servers available that you can attach to one of any router's Ethernet (LAN) ports. These include HP's MediaSmart Servers and the Media Hubs from Linksys. Finally, even while wireless speed has been increasing, so has wired speed. Historically, Fast Ethernet increased transfer rates from 10 to 100 megabits per second (Mbit/s). Gigabit Ethernet increases the speed to 1000 Mbit/s. N-type wireless routers with Gigabit Ethernet delivery include the D-Link Xtreme N Gigabit Router and Linksys Ultra RangePlus Wireless-N Broadband Router.

No matter which wireless router you choose, the benefits will accrue as you discover the freedom of using notebooks, netbooks, media receivers, Internet radios, streaming Blu-ray Disc players, Wi-Fi picture frames, VoIP phones, touch media players, handheld game players, Eye-Fi card-installed cameras and more without necessarily being tethered to a jack.

A more detailed comparison of wireless routers mentioned in this article follows.

Manufacturer Model Wi-Fi Types Antenna LAN RJ-45 Ports Other Port(s) or Slots Security Special Features
Aluratek WMQ137AM g/b 1x external 1x 1x RJ-45 WAN ; PCMCIA card slot; 1x USB WEP, WPA/WPA2 3G cellular support
Apple MC340LL/A n/a/g/b internal integrated 3x 1x RJ-45 WAN; 1x USB; security slot WPA/WPA2, 40- and 128-bit WEP Simultaneous dual-N band; USB port for shared printer or storage; Gigabit LAN
Belkin F5D8235-4 n/g/b 2x external 4x 1x RJ-45 WAN; 1x USB 256-bit WPA/WPA2-Personal, and 64-bit and 128-bit WEP USB port for storage; Gigabit LAN; speedometer bar; MIMO technology; pushbutton security
Bountiful BWRG1000 g/b 2x external 4x 1x RJ-45 WAN 64-/128-bit WEP, 802.1x, WPA-PSK Long range coverage
D-Link DIR-450 g/b 1x external 4x PCMCIA card slot 64/128-bit WEP, WPA, WPA2 3G mobile for cellular EV-DO Networks
D-Link DIR-615 n/g/b 2x external 4x 1x RJ-45 WAN WPA, WPA2  
D-Link DIR-655 n/g/b 3x external 4x 1x RJ-45WAN; 1x USB WPA, WPA2 USB for printer or storage sharing; Gigabit LAN
D-Link DIR-825 n/a/g/b 2x external 4x 1x RJ-45 WAN; 1x USB WPA, WPA2, WPS (PIN & PBC)

USB for printer or storage sharing; Simultaneous dual-band transmission; Gigabit LAN

Linksys WRT110 g/b 2x internal 4x 1x RJ-45 WAN 128/256-bit WEP, WPA, WPA2  
Linksys WRT120N n/g/b 2x internal 4x 1x RJ-45 WAN WPA-2, WEP, Wireless MAC Filtering  
Linksys WRT160N n/g/b 2x internal 4x 1x RJ-45 WAN 128/256-bit WEP, WPA, WPA2 MIMO technology
Linksys WRT160NL n/g/b 2x external 4x 1x RJ-45 WAN; 1x USB 2.0 64/128-bit WEP, WPA, WPA2, RADIUS, SPI Firewall USB port for storage; MIMO technology
Linksys WRT610N n/a/g/b 3x internal 4x 1x RJ-45 WAN; 1x USB 2.0 128-bit WEP, WPA, WPA2 Simultaneous dual-N band; Gigabit LAN; USB port for storage
Netgear MBR624GU-100NAS g/b 1x external 4x 1x USB 2.0 WPA2-PSK, WPA-PSK, WEP, WPA-802.1x, WPA2-802.1x USB-attached docking station for your 3G broadband modem
Netgear WGR614NA g/b 1x external 4x 1x RJ-45 WAN 40/64-, 128- and 152-bit WEP (802.11g only), WPA  
Netgear DG834GNA g/b 1x external 4x 1x RJ-45 WAN; 1x RJ-11 DSL WPA-PSK, WPA2-PSK, WEP, WPA-802.1x, WPA2-802.1x Built-in DSL modem
Netgear DGN2000-100NAS n/g/b 2x external 4x 1x RJ-11 DSL WPA2-PSK, WPA-PSK, 64/128-bit WEP Built-in DSL modem

Add new comment

How well do they work enclosed in a steel building?

I am presently using an air card to connect to the internet as it is the only high speed connection I can get besides satellite.  I my service is through NTelos and Sprint when there is no signal available for NTelos. The mobile broad band card I am using is a Novatel Ovation MC727  3.1 Mbps. 

  I am considering getting a Mac Book to use in another part of the house and when I travel. Which would be the best router for me to get? 

 Gamble Bowers